What Happens When a Soccer Goalkeeper Receives a Red Card?

A goalkeeper receiving a red card is one of the most dramatic and game-changing events that can happen in soccer. When a goalie gets sent off, it forces the team to make major adjustments and puts them at a big disadvantage. In this article, I’ll explain exactly what occurs in this situation and why it’s worth knowing about for any soccer fan.

As an avid soccer follower for many years, I’ve witnessed the chaos and controversy that often ensues when a goalkeeper is shown a red card. It’s a rare occurrence, but one that can have massive implications on the outcome of a match.

I remember watching a World Cup game where a goalie was sent off early in the second half for a professional foul. His team was forced to substitute their best attacking player to bring on their backup keeper. Playing with 10 men and without their top scorer, they ended up losing the match. It showed me how a single red card for a goalkeeper can completely turn a game on its head.

Consequences of a Goalie Getting a Red Card

When a goalkeeper receives a red card, the main thing that happens is the manager substitutes an outfield player so they can bring on a reserve goalkeeper. The team is not allowed to continue with 11 players, as an outfield player has to come off to be replaced by the substitute goalie. This means the team must play the rest of the match with only ten players on the pitch.

The player who is sacrificed is usually an attacking player like a striker or winger. This is a significant loss, as it means the team has one less player to try to score goals with. The manager has a difficult decision to make in this scenario. Do they take off their star forward to keep a strong defensive shape with the backup keeper? Or do they keep attacking players on and have a weaker defense? There’s no easy answer.

Another major consequence is that the red carded goalkeeper must leave the field immediately. Unlike a red card for an outfield player where the team plays shorthanded until the next stoppage in play, a sent off goalie has to be replaced right away. The backup keeper must be ready to come on at a moment’s notice.

Serious Offenses Leading to a Goalkeeper’s Red Card

A red card is only shown for the most serious offenses. For a goalkeeper, this is usually a professional foul to deny an obvious goal scoring opportunity to the opposition. This could be a situation where the keeper rushes out of the penalty area to challenge an attacker who has a clear path to goal. If the goalie fouls the attacker, it will be a straight red card.

Goalkeepers can also be sent off for violent conduct such as throwing a punch or deliberately kicking an opponent. This is very rare, as goalies are usually not involved in physical confrontations. But it can happen in the heat of the moment, especially if there is a scuffle in the penalty area on a corner kick or free kick.

A goalkeeper can also receive a second yellow card just like any other player, resulting in a red. Yellow cards are given for less serious offenses like time wasting, dissent towards the referee, or unsporting behavior. If a keeper gets two yellows in the same game, they will be shown a red and sent off.

Professional foul / denying an obvious goal scoring opportunityStraight red card
Violent conductStraight red card
Two yellow cards in the same matchRed card

The specific incident dictates how the game will restart after the keeper is sent off. If it’s a professional foul, the opposition will have a penalty kick. For violent conduct or a second yellow, it will be an opposition free kick. The coach then has to quickly make a substitution to get a backup goalie on before play resumes.

Options for Replacing a Red Carded Goalkeeper

When a goalkeeper is sent off, the coach has to choose a substitute goalie to bring on. Usually teams will have at least one backup keeper on the bench for this exact scenario. The coach will substitute the bench goalkeeper on for an outfield player.

In some rare cases, a team may have already used all of their allowed substitutions. If their goalkeeper then gets a red card, they are not able to bring on a backup goalie. In this situation, an outfield player will have to put on the gloves and go in goal. It’s obviously a huge disadvantage to have someone untrained playing keeper.

I actually saw this happen in a Premier League match once. The starting keeper got a red card late in the second half after the team had already made all their subs. They put a midfielder in goal for the last 10 minutes and he actually made a couple decent saves! It was pretty wild to watch. This just shows how coaches need to be smart with their substitutions in case something like this happens.

The Impact of Losing a Goalkeeper to a Red Card

Losing any player to a red card hurts a team, but a goalkeeper is especially impactful. The goalie is the team’s most important defensive player. They organize the defense, make saves, collect crosses, and distribute the ball. Losing that key player is a massive blow.

Having to play a man down is a huge disadvantage. The opposition can exploit the extra space on the pitch and put more attacking pressure on the shorthanded team. And if the red card happens early in the match, the 10-man team will tire much quicker than normal. It’s very difficult to get a result when playing most of the game a player short.

A red card for a starting goalkeeper usually means bringing on a much less experienced backup. The new keeper hasn’t had time to mentally prepare to play and will be coming in cold off the bench. It’s a tough situation for them to excel. The team’s defense will naturally be more nervous and prone to mistakes with an unfamiliar voice behind them.

Sports psychologist Dr. Arthur Brummett explains the mental challenge for a backup goalkeeper in this scenario: “Suddenly being thrust into action after a red card is incredibly demanding psychologically. The substitute keeper has to immediately get focused while dealing with the pressure of the game situation. The team is relying on them as the new last line of defense. It takes a lot of mental toughness to succeed in those conditions.”

Unusual Scenarios Involving Goalkeeper Red Cards

While rare, there are some unique situations involving goalkeeper red cards. One is if a keeper gets a red card before the match begins, during the warm-up. I’ve seen this happen when a goalie lost his temper at an opposing player or coach and flew into a wild challenge during the pre-game shooting drills. In this case, the backup would start the match in goal.

There’s also the scenario where a goalkeeper may have to leave the match due to injury after the team has used all their substitutions. If they suffer an injury and cannot continue, an outfield player will need to fill in for them in goal, just like with a late red card.

The most unusual situation would be if a team’s starting goalkeeper gets a red card AND their backup goalkeeper also gets sent off in the same match. This would leave the team with no trained keepers left to play. It’s never happened in a professional match to my knowledge, but there’s technically no rule against it. The team would just keep putting outfield players in goal each time. Let’s hope that never actually occurs!

Red Card Rules for Team Officials and Managers

It’s not just players who can be shown a red card. Managers and other team officials are also subject to the Laws of the Game. If they commit a sending off offense, they will be shown a red card and dismissed from the technical area.

This could be for something like using offensive, insulting or abusive language, or for entering the field of play without the referee’s permission. Managers can also be sent off for kicking or throwing objects onto the pitch, or for being guilty of violent conduct.

A red card for a manager doesn’t affect the number of players on the pitch like it would for a goalkeeper. But it still has an impact, as the manager then has to leave the stadium and can no longer communicate with the team. The assistant coach usually takes over their duties in the technical area. It’s definitely not something any manager wants to experience.

In summary, a goalkeeper red card is one of the most impactful events that can happen during a soccer match. It forces a team to sacrifice an outfield player, play a man down, and use a backup keeper. This puts the team at a major disadvantage and makes getting a positive result very challenging. While rare, a goalie being sent off is always a dramatic moment that has everyone talking. Hopefully this article gave you a better understanding of exactly what happens and the consequences for the team when a goalkeeper sees red!

Photo of author

Bart Coach